Top Operations: Tilcon New York’s Haverstraw Quarry
Optimization helped Haverstraw Quarry increase its production of saleable material.
by Kerry Clines, Senior Editor
Editor’s Note: This article originally appeared in the November 2011 issue of Aggregates Manager.
Haverstraw Quarry is located on the Hudson River just north of New York City. The 157-acre quarry was originally owned by the New York Trap Rock Co., which opened the quarry in 1923. The quarry passed through the hands of a number of other owners before Tilcon New York bought it in 1981.
The main pit is located on the backside of a 525-foot mountain that faces the river. Though currently at an elevation of 100 feet below sea level, the pit was originally at an elevation of about 400 feet on the side of the mountain. At that time, haul trucks carried the rock from the pit, down the side of the mountain, to the road below for shipment. A special cable system was set up to allow a fully loaded haul truck traveling down the mountain to pull an empty haul truck up the mountain to the pit. “It was kind of like a trolley system,” says Lenny Tellone, a Tilcon employee and former plant manager at Haverstraw Quarry. “The quarry ran that way until about 1950.”
In 1988, a few years after purchasing the quarry, Tilcon began construction of a tunnel through the mountain, underneath the highway (9W) and the railroad tracks, to the river. Construction was completed in the spring of 1990, at which time the secondary plant was moved to the river side of the tunnel, as were the stockpiles and loadout area, making access to the river for barge transport much easier.
“The tunnel is 1,000 feet long through the rock and about 21 feet in diameter with a concrete floor,” Tellone says. “A 56-inch conveyor goes through the tunnel along with power lines in the roof. We tied the conveyor into the primary and into the screen towers in the secondary. It cost a lot to do it, but it was the only way we could get to the river.”
A tunnel with conveyors and chutes runs beneath the stockpiles by the river, allowing specific materials to be sent to the dock for loading. “When things are busy, we load four or five barges a day — about 1,000 tons per barge,” says John Rufer, current plant manager at Haverstraw Quarry. “Right now, we’re a little bit slower. We’re loading two or three barges a day. We’re very conscious of not allowing anything to get into the river. We have to minimize the effect on our neighbors and the environment.”
Haverstraw Quarry has made an effort to minimize the amount of blasting at the quarry, as well, by making larger shots once or twice a week instead of smaller shots four times a week. “We spend a lot of money making sure the right controls are in place so we’re not affecting the neighbors too much,” Rufer says. “We have to in order to stay in business.”
Tilcon has an asphalt plant located on site that uses some of the material processed in the quarry, but a majority of the aggregate is shipped to New York City and Long Island for use in construction projects. About two-thirds of the material is shipped by truck and the rest by barge on the Hudson River. “We really want it the other way around, but that’s the way the sales are going this year,” Rufer says. “Barge transportation is a lot cheaper than trucking. It’s a competitive advantage for us.”
One interesting fact, according to Tellone, is that Haverstraw Quarry is the only quarry that dissects the Palisades formation — the five-sided columns of rock found in the area. “It’s a vertical column of rock that varies in width from 12 to 18 inches,” Tellone says. “If it gets bigger than that, it starts losing the formation. Geologists come to the quarry to study the rock formation.”
Optimizing the plant
During the winter months, the plant closes down and workers are laid off while winter maintenance is performed. The time is used for making changes that would normally cause a shutdown during the production season. This year, Haverstraw Quarry used the winter months to optimize its production system, replacing an outdated 1980’s control system with an updated Rockwell PLC-based process control system.
“Our biggest selling products here are our asphalt fractions — 1/4-, 3/8-, and 1/2-inch,” Rufer says, “and we can never make enough. We were trying to figure out how to maximize production of asphalt fractions with our regular crushing operation. That was one of our main objectives in upgrading control of the crushing process at Haverstraw.”
Alan Bessen, P.E., served as a consultant and project manager during the automation process. “When people in the aggregate business think of automation,” Bessen says, “they often think in terms of merely automating start/stop sequencing. In this case, we replaced an obsolete PLC and associated software with a new Rockwell control system configured to manage standard start/stop and equipment monitoring functions, including a new Rockwell PLC and an updated operator interface.”
Performance monitoring instrumentation was also added, including 15 belt scales that provide product yield data to the plant operator, enabling him to manage the yield of key products by making process adjustments in real-time. The new control interface will be automated in the second phase to use both current and historical data, enabling the computer to track, report, and adjust key process variables in real-time.
“I’m working on the advanced performance management stage with Sam Sawant, a crusher specialist with Innotech Solutions,” Bessen says. “Sam designed two of the key crushers in the system. We’ve been adjusting those crushers to optimize the yield of key products with great success, using the belt scale systems for feedback on both current yield and system capacity.” The feedback is presented to the operator, giving him the information he needs to make appropriate changes in feed rate, recrush setting, and crusher setting to improve performance.
“There’s nothing magic about automation in a quarry,” Bessen adds. “We take big rocks and make them into little rocks. Making the most money out of it in the process comes back to how you control the yield of products to get the most saleable product with the least by-products and waste. Improving profit is the reason for automating the performance management system.”
The plant processes the same amount of stone, but produces more saleable fractions instead of making larger stone that doesn’t have a market or has to go back for recrushing.
“Our crushers and scales are tied together so we can see what’s going on at any one time,” Rufer says. “We make product according to the program, not just according to what an operator decides to do. Instead of ending up with a bunch of material that we have trouble selling, we have the flexibility to make more of our hot products. The new system lets us make small adjustments to maximize production of the products we want to make. Before, we just crushed and got whatever came out.”
Before the new system was added, production of 3/8-inch product averaged 120 to 130 tons per hour. With the new system in place, the quarry hit a new record for 3/8-inch production in September of more than 250 tons per hour — essentially doubling prior production capabilities.
The new system allows employees to extract downtime, uptime, and what types of products are being made at any given time from anywhere. “We can see what’s going on, in real-time, no matter where we are,” Rufer says. “I can bring it up on my laptop at home. I can see how many tons of material are coming off any conveyor belt at any stage in the plant. I can check the production rate for the day and get a running graph of what products we’re making for the entire day.”
Phase II of the automation project, planned for this winter season, will tie up a few loose ends. “We’re seeing that we need to make a few changes,” Rufer says. “We want the crushers to interact with the new computer system, so the crushers can adjust on their own according to gradations that come off our belts at the time. I believe that will be the final touch to really take it to the next level, but you always want to stay one step ahead.”
Production levels at Haverstraw Quarry have been declining over the last several years. “Back in 2004, we produced about 2.8 million tons,” Rufer says. “This year, we’ll make about 1.35 million tons. This used to be a 24-hour operation — we ran three shifts and were off on Sundays only. Now, we’re running one production shift of eight to 12 hours and an eight-hour shift dedicated to maintenance. And we’re not working as many weekends. We’re still going, but we’re not going as much as we’d like to.”
In order to stay alive, the quarry has gone to a lean manufacturing concept. It currently has 38 hourly employees and six salaried employees — a drop from 93 employees back in 2005.
Each job is being closely scrutinized to see if there’s a better way of doing it. Employees are being cross-trained to make sure they can do many different jobs.
“When you look at the drop in demand, you have to look at ways to keep or increase your profits,” Rufer says. “It’s necessary. We’re kind of lean and mean now. We don’t have a lot of extra people around. With the cross-training and restructuring of all our jobs, we’ve become much more proficient.”
Caterpillar 992 wheel loaders (2)
Caterpillar 988 wheel loaders (3)
Caterpillar 980 wheel loader
Kawasaki Z 115 wheel loader
Hitachi 450 excavator
Hitachi 540 LR excavator
Komatsu HD605 haul trucks (4)
Caterpillar 773 50-ton haul truck
Terex T.A. 40-ton haul truck
Svedala 50-inch x 65-inch gyratory crusher
Svedala 384AC crusher
Metso HP 300 crusher
Metso HP 500 crushers (2)
Sandvik H-4000 crusher
Sandvik H-3000 crushers (2)
Simplicity double-deck screen
Astec external RAP system
8 x 20 triple-deck screens (2)
8 x 24 triple-deck screens (10)
8,000-foot conveyor system
5-ton H&B batch plant
Hot bins (5)
Cold-feed bins (8)
250-ton silos (2)
MORE FROM Articles
SUBSCRIBE & FOLLOW
- Miner suspended upside down pulled to safety by his pant legs717 Views
- MSHA and NSSGA release new infographic about material handling injuries326 Views
- Caterpillar to close Kentucky plant, cut 50 jobs216 Views
- Democratic senators call for shorter highway bill in order to maximize funding169 Views
- Transportation funding extended through Dec. 4 as House and Senate work out long-term bill104 Views